JPDU Spring Tournament 2016


大会概要

日時 2016年4月23日(土), 24日(日)
会場 4/26 横浜市立大学 金沢八景キャンパス
4/27 国際基督教大学
参加対象 大学に所属する、全てのディベーター(学部生・大学院生は問わない)
ディベート形式 – Asian-style (3 on 3)
– Constructive Speech: 7minutes
– Reply Speech: 4 minutes
– Preparation Time: 30min, 3-motion制, POIあり、POOなし
大会形式 予選:4ラウンド
メインブレイク:16
ルーキーブレイク: 8
備考 16チームブレイク
ルーキーブレイクあり(8チーム)

■Results■

■Team Prize

Main

Champion
Tokyo A (東京大学)
Mayu Arimoto, Keita Kurita, Hirohito Asai

Grand Finalist
WAD A (早稲田大学)
Alex Taylor, Lewis Won, Shingo Fujita

Semi Finalists
ICU A (国際基督教大学)
Sara Takehara, Chiaki Hagimoto, Allison Cruyff VF.Ladero

KDS A (慶應大学)
Tom Ohtsuka, Kasumi Nogawa, Sho Masada

Quarter Finalists
Osaka A (大阪大学)
Yohei Nakanishi/Nobuya Nishikawa/Nana Chishima
WAD B (早稲田大学)
Niu Yihao, Tamane Sasaki, Sol Lee
Tokyo B (東京大学)
Masahito Omori, Kanako Hayashi, Hiroyuki Shibuya
Tokyo F (東京大学)
Ryo Hiramoto, Mina Hamada, Ayaka Watanabe

Oct Finalists
Titech A (東京工業大学)
Heyshiro Kanagawa, Masahiro Hayashi, Yutaro Totsuka
ICU B (国際基督教大学)
Mana Hideshima, Takuto Toyama, Kana Hatano
KDS B (慶應大学)
Shimon Nakayama, Kenshin Nakahara, Kentaro Toshiba
Tokyo C (東京大学)
Masaya Sasaki, Takuto Futamura, Kiyoshi Kawakami
Tokyo D (東京大学)
Ken Kuroki, Maki Minemura, Miho Horie
Tokyo G (東京大学)
Julia Sakai, Riko Ishimaru, Teppei Shibuta
KDS C (慶應大学)
Masahiro Michigami, Chihiro Toya, Kotaro Asano
WAD D (早稲田大学)
Mas Urano, Mizuki Sanjo, Shun Motokawa

Rookie

Rookie Champion
Tokyo E (東京大学)
Julius Cueto, Tomoko Yagasaki, Kohdai Kuroiwa

Rookie Finalist
Hit-U A (一橋大学)
Yuriko Sugimoto, Azusa Iida, Akifumi Momose

Rookie Semi Finalist
Hit-U B (一橋大学)
Kosuke Shoji, Harumi Sekido, Hikaru Tsuzuki

KDS E (慶應大学)
Kae Natsume, Atsushi Sumida, Sae Kobayashi

Rookie Quarter Finalists
ICU C (国際基督教大学)
Miki Tanaka, Yusuke Hara, Erika Suzuki

ICU D (国際基督教大学)
Kiriko Terai, Kaen Ikemoto, Subaru Arakane

ICU E (国際基督教大学)
Sato Yoshimura, Sho Yurimoto, Naoya Scott Johnson

Hit-U E (一橋大学)
Atsuki Okada, Hirotaka Nedachi, Yuji Masumura

■Speaker Prize

Grand Final Best Speaker
Keita Kurita(Tokyo A)

Main

The Best Speaker
Alex Taylor (WAD A)
Keita Kurita (Tokyo A)

The 3nd Best Speaker
Hirohito Asai (Tokyo A)
Mayu Arimoto (Tokyo A)

The 5th Best Speaker
Shingo Fujita (WAD A)

The 5th Best Speaker
Sho Masuda (KDS A)

The 6th Best Speaker
Shingo Fujita (WAD A)

The 7th Best Speaker
Allison Cryuff VF. Ladero (ICU A)

The 8th Best Speaker
Shimon Nakayama (KDS B)

The 9th Best Speaker
Sawa Takehara (ICU A)

The 10th Best Speaker
Tom Ohtsuka (KDS A)

Rookie

1st Best Rookie Speaker
Kotaro Asano (KDS C)
Mina Hamada (Tokyo F)

3rd Best Rookie Speaker
Ryo Hiramoto(Tokyo F)

4th Best Rookie Speaker
Mas Urano(WAD D)

5th Best Rookie Speaker
Hikaru Tsuzuki(Hit-U B)

■Judge Award

Best Adjudicator
Satoru Nabeshima

2nd Best Adjudicator
Yuki Oka

3rd Best Adjudicator
Ryoya Kurauchi

4th Best Adjudicator
Hiroki Yokoyama
Tomoya Yonaga
Ryo Hayakawa

■Breaking Adjudicator
Chikara Mizokami(CA)
Chin Yi Chow
Chizuru Yamazaki
Daigo Kimura
Darla Cornett
Hiroki Yokoyama
Ibuki Kudo
Isao Ayabe
Jumpei Sekiguchi(DCA)
Kazuki Tokunaga
Kohei Toba
Kotaro Minami
Marina Nakamura
Masako Ishihara
Masako Suzuki Takahashi
Momoka Hayashida
Nanami Hara(DCA)
Naoki Enomoto(DCA)
Naoki Kobayashi
Ryo Hayakawa
Ryo Watanabe
Ryota Kosuge(DCA)
Ryoya Kurauchi
Satoru Nabeshima
Shunsuke Kanda
Takuya Kitaoka
Takuya Yoda
Tomoya Yonaga
Yosuke Amagai
Yuki Oka
Daichi Tanaka(Reserved)
Emi Yamaguchi(Reserved)
Hiro Sakagawa(Reserved)
Manayo Sunaga(Reserved)
Risa Shishikura(Reserved)
Takahiro Mikura(Reserved)

■Motions■
Round1:きぎょう
THW ban unpaid internships
THW not allow companies to have financial settlements with attacking hackers
THW force large companies who leave an area to pay the cost of any resulting structural unemployment

Round2:せいぎ(まさよし)
THW decriminalize murder with consent
THBT illegally gathered evidence and information should be admissible in criminal trials
THW introduce the jury system

Round3:うまん
THW ban the photo manipulation of people’s appearance on products and advertisements
THBT the feminist movement should oppose the development of sexbots
-sexbot: humanoids with AI that are designed for sexual purposes
THBT the feminist movement should condemn the hook-up culture
-hook-up culture: a culture which accepts and encourages casual sexual encounters focused on physical pleasure, without necessarily including emotional bonding

Round4:いーすとひがしてぃもーる
THS slum tourism
THBT newly democratised multiethnic states should ban ethnic political parties
THW break up Megacities
-megacity: A metropolitan area with a population above ten million people

Rookie Quarter Final:せいじ
THW allow public servants to express their political views in public
THBT politicians should not use sensational rhetoric (e.g. War on Terror, Axis of evil) in public
THW give more votes to the poor

Rookie Semi Final:えこのみー
THBT the state should introduce a basic income system (with info-slide)
THBT developing countries should nationalize its natural resourses
THW allow the trade of endangered animals

Info-slide
Basic Income System
-Basic Income System provides a set amount of income to every citizen. It is given irrespective of any other income source, your willingness or performance in work.
-For example, Switzerland is to have a referendum on whether to introduce basic income of 2500 CHF (約30万円) per month to adults and 625 CHF (約7万5千円) to those underage.
-The budget of this plan is expected to be covered by tax revenue and by cutting part of the current social welfare service.

Rookie Grand Final:いろいろ
THBT the state should not fund contemporary art
THBT handicapped entertainer should refrain from using their disability in a comical or self-deprecating manner to humor the audience
THBT environmental activists should never use violence as a strategy to forward their cause

Octo Final:こども
THW implement a parenting liscence
THW allow single parents in prison to raise their children behind bars
THBT schools should remove all restriction on students’ appearance(e.g. clothes, hairstyle, makeup)

Quarter Final:あいあーる
THBT the EU should abolish the “Schengen Area”
-Schengen Area: A collective of European nations that have abolished passports and other types of border control at their common borders.
THBT the international community should impose sanctions on tax havens
THW, as China, cease all political and economic support to North Korea

Semi Final:げんろん
THBT political correctness today does more harm than good to social discourse
THBT when discussing social justice issues, the identity of a speaker should not be used to limit their participation in discussion or to criticize their points
THW punish those who endorse others not to participate in politics

Grand Final:かがく
THBT nuclear energy policies should not be decided through referenda
THW program self-driving cars to always prioritize the safety of its own passengers
THBT the academia has a moral obligation to seek and disprove psuedo-science (e.g. hydrogen water, negative ion)

Organizing Committee

Tournament Director Takashi Imai (上智大学)
Vice Tournament Director Akari Sekiguchi (国際基督教大学)
Chief Adjudicator Chikara Mizokami (東京大学)
Deputy Chief Adjudicator Jumpei Sekiguchi (国際基督教大学)
Nanami Hara (慶應義塾大学)
Naoki Enomoto (東京工業大学)
Ryota Kosuge (大阪大学)
Communication Director Ryota Yoshii (神奈川大学)
Financial Director Kana Hatano (国際基督教大学)
Media Director Jin Yoshikawa (東京大学)
Tournament Coordinator Yuika Kayamori (上智大学)
Tabulation Director Hideo Takas (芝浦工業大学)
Vice Tabulation Director Haruki Koma (東京大学)